Nantucket, an idyllic island off the coast of Massachusetts, is renowned not only for its picturesque beaches and historic charm but also for its culinary offerings. Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, a cozy brunch spot, or a fine dining experience, Nantucket has it all. In this guide, we’ve compiled a list of the best restaurants on the island, where you can indulge in everything from casual eats to upscale dining.
1. The Proprietors Bar & Table
Located in the heart of Nantucket’s historic district, The Proprietors Bar & Table offers a contemporary twist on New England cuisine. The menu features fresh, locally sourced ingredients, and the dishes are as creative as they are flavorful. Whether you’re in the mood for a juicy steak, fresh seafood, or a seasonal vegetable dish, you won’t be disappointed.
- Why You’ll Love It: Exceptional service, a cozy atmosphere, and an innovative menu.
- Specialty: Try their signature cocktails and seasonal dishes that highlight local produce.
- Website: The Proprietors Bar & Table
2. Cru
For those looking to enjoy waterfront dining with stunning views, Cru is the place to be. With a modern and chic ambiance, this upscale seafood restaurant offers a wide variety of seafood dishes, including oysters, lobster rolls, and fish tacos. Don’t forget to pair your meal with one of their expertly crafted cocktails or a glass of wine from their extensive selection.
- Why You’ll Love It: The view of Nantucket Harbor and their famous raw bar.
- Specialty: Fresh oysters, lobster, and seafood platters.
- Website: Cru Nantucket
3. The Saltbox Kitchen
Located in the charming Sconset area, The Saltbox Kitchen offers a delightful menu of farm-to-table dishes with an emphasis on local, seasonal ingredients. This cozy eatery is the perfect spot for a casual yet delicious meal, serving up everything from creative salads to hearty meats and seafood.
- Why You’ll Love It: A relaxed atmosphere and a focus on sustainable, farm-fresh food.
- Specialty: The rotisserie chicken and vegetable-focused dishes.
- Website: The Saltbox Kitchen
4. Nantucket Whaling Company
If you’re looking for a fine dining experience with a sophisticated yet laid-back vibe, Nantucket Whaling Company is the perfect choice. The restaurant serves a variety of New England-inspired dishes, including steaks, seafood, and locally sourced produce. The interior is elegant, and the service is top-notch.
- Why You’ll Love It: A welcoming ambiance and an exceptional wine list.
- Specialty: The filet mignon and the Nantucket seafood chowder.
- Website: Nantucket Whaling Company
5. Straight Wharf Restaurant
Nestled on the docks, Straight Wharf Restaurant is one of Nantucket’s most beloved spots for fresh seafood. With a beautiful view of the harbor, this restaurant offers a perfect combination of great food and stunning scenery. The menu is focused on fresh, seasonal ingredients and is heavily influenced by local seafood offerings.
- Why You’ll Love It: Waterfront dining with some of the best seafood in town.
- Specialty: Grilled fish and lobster dishes.
- Website: Straight Wharf Restaurant
6. The Juice Bar
For a sweet treat on a sunny Nantucket day, head to The Juice Bar. Known for its homemade ice cream, this family-friendly establishment has been serving the island’s visitors and locals since 1974. They offer a wide range of ice cream flavors, sundaes, and other delicious desserts.
- Why You’ll Love It: Perfect for a quick dessert or a casual snack after a day at the beach.
- Specialty: Classic Nantucket ice cream and sundaes.
- Website: The Juice Bar
7. Galley Beach
If you want to enjoy a fine dining experience right on the beach, Galley Beach is the place to go. This beachfront restaurant offers delicious seafood dishes with a stunning view of Nantucket Sound. It’s a great spot to watch the sunset while indulging in some of the island’s best seafood.
- Why You’ll Love It: Beachfront dining with panoramic views and excellent food.
- Specialty: Lobster, clams, and beachside cocktails.
- Website: Galley Beach
8. Bartlett’s Farm Market & Kitchen
For a more casual but delightful dining experience, head over to Bartlett’s Farm Market & Kitchen. Known for its farm-to-table meals and fresh, local ingredients, this market and restaurant offer a variety of dishes, from gourmet sandwiches to fresh salads, making it a perfect lunch spot.
- Why You’ll Love It: Fresh, healthy options that emphasize local ingredients.
- Specialty: The daily sandwich specials and salads.
- Website: Bartlett’s Farm
9. The Boarding House
Located in a beautifully restored historic building, The Boarding House offers a relaxed atmosphere paired with an outstanding menu. The menu features an eclectic mix of New England favorites and international dishes, with an emphasis on fresh, seasonal ingredients.
- Why You’ll Love It: The unique ambiance and inventive dishes.
- Specialty: Lobster ravioli and grilled fish.
- Website: The Boarding House
10. The Downyflake
If you’re craving a delicious breakfast or brunch, The Downyflake is a local favorite. Known for its classic American breakfast fare, including pancakes, eggs, and freshly baked donuts, this cozy spot has been serving the Nantucket community for over 80 years.
- Why You’ll Love It: Classic American breakfast dishes and friendly service.
- Specialty: The Downyflake donut and their pancakes.
- Website: The Downyflake
Conclusion
Nantucket’s restaurant scene is as diverse as its natural beauty. Whether you’re in the mood for a fine dining experience with a harbor view, a casual beachside bite, or a traditional New England breakfast, there’s something for everyone. Be sure to check out these top spots on your next visit, and enjoy the rich flavors and island hospitality that make Nantucket a must-visit culinary destination.
For more information on Nantucket’s restaurant scene, you can also explore these helpful external resources: